A SENSE OF PROPORTION

ELIZABETH phones to say the church coffee morning tomorrow (10.00am, Saturday) won’t after all be for, or even in, the church. They’ve decided the money will go instead to Christian Aid for the people of Haiti whose homes and lives have been devastated by the earthquake. The change of venue to the village hall – next door to the chapel – is because the heating isn’t working in the church.

This leads me to bemoan our own loss of heating. Not to the downstairs, where we live, but the upstairs, where we don’t. It’s bitterly cold up there and we can’t get a plumber for love nor money. Should we buy a new fan heater? Or maybe one of those Dimplex things would be better, I suggest to Ian.

I’m pondering all this while still under the duvet with the radio on and hearing – though not always actually listening to – reports of people who’ve lost everything but their life, sleeping alongside the bodies of those who’ve lost even that,  in the car park of a hospital which has next to nothing: no doctors, no nurses, few beds, hardly any medical supplies.

John Humphrys interviews the Archbishop of York, John Sentamu, to ask a question he seems to ask a lot: Where was God in all this? The archbishop has an answer which, though I could hear every word of it, made no sense whatever to me, to Ian or to John Humphrys. It seemed to boil down, as it usually does with theologians and bishops (not always the same thing), to “God is in the midst of it.”  The best explanation that anyone’s come up with for faith in the face of natural – or even man-made –  disasters. I’m not convinced.

I get up and realise I need to get on with baking the cakes I’ve promised for the coffee morning. It’s a pathetically small gesture, as even a donation equivalent to the cost of a Dimplex would be, but in the face of monumental catastrophe the only alternative would be to get back under the duvet.

There are those who would argue that this is precisely the point: God is in the small gestures, from countless millions of people – regardless of religious affiliation or belief – who are, for the most part, hard-wired for altruism. I’m still not convinced: but at least I know the duvet isn’t an option.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “A SENSE OF PROPORTION

  1. I think that there is more to the question than God being in the small gestures of countless people. I do believe that God is in those gestures but it is my belief that God is also present in the suffering because he suffered with us, in the human form of Jesus, and continues to feel the pain that all humanity feels. God is present in the comfort, love and support.
    If however, the question is why does God not prevent this that is a different point altogether and assumes that God is free to intervene in any and all human actions.But that woukd be to deny humanity the freedom to choose as intervention in one action would mean intervention in all and if that were the case we would be no more than automota, under the control of God for good or ill.
    Ian

  2. Finding God in the midst of such utter horror and devastation is never easy – looking out over the snow-glistening fields towards Addleborough, the work of His Hand is perfectly illustrated – but some of the images coming out of Haiti make it much more challenging. I can bake cakes; fill my life with the small gestures; rally others to do the same – but answers seem along way away.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s